MLK Memorial: Plagued with Controversy

Ever since the announcement came through that Martin Luther King Jr was receiving a memorial at the National Mall many, including me, believed it was a long time coming. An individual who worked so hard to achieve freedom and equality for all in this country and sought to make this world a better place deserves to be remembered by all who tour the capitol of the United States. Tragically the memory of King has been stained with controversy after controversy since the beginning not making it worth the wait.

It started with the King family and their company Intellectual Properties Management. This organization has sadly spent years capitalizing off King’s name and reputation rather than believing that his words and inspiration are meant for the betterment of all mankind. They expected the Memorial Foundation to pay them handsomely for the rights to use King’s image and his quotes on the memorial. This process delay design and construction. Various individuals spoke out against this idea believing that if no one is making money off the memorial then why should they receive a fee. Despite that the Associated Press reported that the King family negotiated a licensing deal of nearly $800,000 in order to build this memorial. How ridiculous is this? In order to honor one of the country’s greatness individuals we have to pay someone to use his likeness and words. One can not help but question the motives of the King family and their desire require a license for this memorial.

In 2007, it was announced that a Chinese sculptor had been designated as the creator of the King memorial. This turned out a massive outcry and as human rights activists pointed out the sculptor had also sculpted an image of Mao Zedong. Gilbert Young, an African-American sculptor and artist, created a website dedicated to protesting this decision. He believed that African-Americans should be designated as the designer and builders of the memorial. Sadly for the most part this fell on deaf ears. And to add salt to the wound the foundations attempted to appease the protests and state that local builders would be used for the project however when it came time for everything to start, Chinese builders were used, most of them brought over from China to work only on this project.

Finally the most recent controversy is over a quote placed on King’s memorial which was changed and made him look like “an arrogant twit” according to Maya Angelou who was a consultant on the project. The quote from King originally said "If you want to say that I was a drum major, say that I was a drum major for justice. Say that I was a drum major for peace. I was a drum major for righteousness. And all of the other shallow things will not matter." However they paraphrased the quote on the memorial and wrote "I was a drum major for justice, peace, and righteousness." Not the greatest phrasing of words for someone who appeared to be very humble and unselfish individual.

It is frustrating to think that the Memorial Foundation would make so many wide ranging mistakes. I question if back room deals were made with Chinese officials to appease them in some way because we can see that it was done with the King family. Personally I feel like it is an embarrassment to the American people and the memory of Martin Luther King Jr. that so many terrible decisions were made in the making of this memorial. I would almost hope they would destroy this current memorial and try again from scratch because I feel like a better, less obtrusive, on could be made. 

http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2012/01/16/obama-volunteers-on-mlk-day-addresses-controversy-over-memorial-inscription/

Christmas History and Facts: The Twelve Days of Christmas

Have you ever seen swans swimming in a pond and thought I should get that as a gift for my sweetie? Yeah me either especially when, according to PNC’s Christmas Price Index, it would cost $6300 to make that happen. As we all know that wonderfully repetitive song, the 12 Days of Christmas which gets played so often this time of year, however if one were to purchase all of those gifts for their significant other it would cost them a whopping $24,263. But seriously who in their right mind would buy all of these gifts for an individual or in what century would someone have purchased turtle doves and men jumping around as a Christmas gift. The question is when and why was this song created?

Many people hear the 12 days of Christmas and believe they are gifts leading up to Christmas Day, the 12^th day, however the first day, a partridge in a pear tree, starts on Christmas Day and ends on January 5^th. The period after Christmas is a Christian celebration dating as far back as the Middle Ages known as Christmastide, Twelvetide, or Yuletide. Whatever the name may be, this period after Christmas is meant for reflection on the birth of Jesus Christ with traditional feasts such as the feast of St. Stephen, which is meant to give leftovers to the poor, along with the feast of John the Evangelist and the feast of the Holy Innocents. Many of these traditions and celebrations vary throughout different countries and various religions. Here in the United States the traditions and celebrations of the Twelve Days of Christmas had largely been forgotten and relegated to a song.  

So the question is what is the origin of the song “The Twelve Days of Christmas”? The song was published for the first time in England in 1780 however many historians believe its origins are French and the song could date back much further than that. Why the song was written and published at the time is unknown. In 1979, a Canadian teacher wrote an article suggesting that the song 12 days were coded catechisms for the Catholic Church. His argument was that the English people were not permitted to practice Catholicism publically from 1558-1829 so they secretly celebrated their traditions of Twelve Night through the song. Here are each of the meanings.

A Partridge in a Pear Tree –          Jesus
Two Turtle Doves  –                          The Old and New Testament
Three French Hens –                        The Kings bearing gifts
Four Callet (Calling) Birds –          The Four Gospels
Five Golden Rings –                          The Pentateuch (first five books of the Bible)
Six Geese-a-Laying –                       The Six Days of Creation
Seven Swans-a-Swimming –          Seven Gifts of the Holy Spirit
Eight Maids-a-Milking –                  The Eight Beatitudes
Nine Ladies Dancing –                     Nine Fruits of the Spirit
Ten Lords-a-Leaping –                     The Ten Commandments
Eleven Pipers Piping –                     Eleven Apostles
Twelve Drummers Drumming –    Twelve Points of the Apostles Creed

However there are some problems in this theory. For one the first mention over the last century about a coded catechism in this song is with this Canadian teacher. The idea had been further perpetrated by religious scholars however with little additional evidence. You would have to believe that there would be more significant sources to back up this claim over the last couple centuries. The other major problem is that most of these meanings are not a departure from the Protestant church. In reality they are directly in line with nearly all major Christian denominations and faiths. The actual origin of the song and its purpose are unknown with ideas ranging from a child’s counting song, to a memory game played during Twelve Night in which the leader would start and would have to memorize the subsequent verses given by the participants. Whatever the purpose and origin of the song one thing we do know is that there are a “Twelve Days of Christmas” which do not lead up to Christmas Day but actually begin then. 

Christmas History and Facts: "Account of a visit by St. Nicholas"

I am very excited about starting our family tradition this Christmas Eve with reading “Twas the night before Christmas” to my son. I would expect this is a typical tradition in many households around the country. The words from the story are so familiar to all of us:

Twas the night before Christmas, when all through the house
Not a creature was stirring, not even a mouse.
The stockings were hung by the chimney with care,
In hopes that St Nicholas soon would be there.

Those lines role off the American tongue like no other story in our history, however what makes this story so famous, why is it so popular. The story was first published December 23, 1823 in the Troy Sentinel, by an anonymous writer under the title “Account of a visit by St. Nicholas.” It is surprising to see that this poems popularity exploded so much when it was buried on page 3 in between random stories and marriage announcements. Despite being credited to an anonymous writer the poem is widely attributed to Clement Clarke Moore, a professor and writer. At the time the poem was written, Christmas Day was slowly surpassing New Year’s Day as the family gathering holiday of the season however many Protestants were apprehensive of the holiday because Christ’s apparent birth was not in the winter months of December. The traditions of Christmas we have today, especially in connection with Santa Claus and gift giving, were not in existence like they are today. The historical figure of St. Nicholas was known by some, especially those who practice Catholicism, for giving generous gifts to the poor. The idea of Santa Claus transcended from there to a Sinterklaas and then a character named Father Christmas from the British tradition. The notion of incorporating characters such as Santa Claus, Father Christmas, or others during the Christmas season was far from the norm. Moore’s story actually helped establish many of our Christmas traditions including the character of Santa Claus that we know and love today. His physical appearance, the night he visits, his sleigh and reindeer, along with the number and names of the reindeer, as well as his mode of operation which involved landing on top of the house and going down the chimney to deliver toys to children all came from Moore’s story.

He was dress’d all in fur, from his head to his foot,
And his clothes were all tarnish’d with ashes and soot;
A bundle of toys was flung on his back,
And he look’d like a peddler just opening his pack:
His eyes – how they twinkled! His dimples how merry,
His cheeks were like roses, his nose like a cherry;
His droll little mouth was drawn up like a bow,
And the beard of his chin was as white as the snow;
The stump of a pipe he held tight in his teeth,
And the smoke it encircled his head like a wreath.
He has a broad face, and a little round belly
That shook when he laugh’d, like a bowl full of jelly:
He was chubby and plump, a right jolly old elf,

The jolly fat man, in a white beard and red suit visiting house to house every night was created by Moore in his story “Account of a Visit from St. Nicholas. New York was one of the first major cities to embrace Moore’s Santa Claus, which saw a large proportion of non-Christian families using Santa Claus as their reason for celebration and gift giving. From there the story of Santa Claus was reproduced over and over again in various versions and from multiple perspectives. Between 1823 and today Santa Claus has grow into a center piece of the American culture and Christmas tradition. People from all over the world have taken this version of Santa and adapted it to fit to their own culture. So as you read and listen to “Twas the Night Before Christmas” this time of year, remember that this is the story that helped give birth to the legend that is Santa Claus.

Christmas History and Facts: The Strange

The history of Christmas is such a fascinating story. Many of us grow up with Santa Claus, Christmas Trees, and mistletoe as just a normal part of the December 25th tradition. However many of these traditions and symbols have a history that do not go back as far as you may think. I have come across so History Channel videos as well as documents which I would like to share that may surprise you or enlighten you on why we celebrate Christmas the way we do and how other people celebrate Christmas that is much different than our own.

This video is from the History Channel which will surprise you in the different ways people have celebrated Christmas.

Thanksgiving Proclamation of 1789

As we all do on this day here in America we gather together with family and friends. Some have traditions of going around the room and telling everyone what they are thankful for, some do it privately as they enjoy the company of family however we all gather for food. It is the cornerstone of this holiday. The turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, and most importantly pies are the reason so many people look forward to this holiday. Yet who among us has ever examined the origin of the holiday. I don’t mean how the pilgrims first sat down with the Indians and had a big meal. I mean the founding of the holiday itself.

In 1789 George Washington established Thanksgiving as a “day of public thanksgiving and prayer to be observed by acknowledging with grateful hearts the many and signal favors of Almighty God, especially affording them an opportunity peaceably to establish a form of government for their safety and happiness.” Thanksgiving, according to Washington’s proclamation, was established to give thanksgiving to God. I know too much of the time historians try to avoid the discussion of God and prayer because it associates this country and our heritage with Christianity. In this case it is a little hard to avoid. Washington continues on stating that the upcoming 26^th of November will be set aside as a day in which it is “to be devoted by the people of these States to the service of that great and glorious Being who is the beneficent author of all the good that was, that is, or that will be; that we may then all unite in rendering unto Him our sincere and humble thanks for His kind care and protection of the people of this country.”

These quotes from the proclamation are simply a sample of the entire letter written by Washington and all of it points to one thing, Thanksgiving was established to gather as a country and give thanks to God for the country we have been provided and the blessings in which we have received as a nation. I understand the immediate reaction of all non-Christian citizens whose first thought is anger at reading how this holiday is centered on God and Christianity. Realistically our society viewed Christianity as a norm. It was a regular part of peoples’ everyday lives and to celebrate a day of thanksgiving to that God would not be seen as out of the ordinary. There is no reason a country we should ignore who we are and how we were established. This does not in any way take away from ones right to practice their own religion or no religion at all. It simply just establishes how this holiday was founded and the mentality of many of our founding fathers including George Washington.

Happy Thanksgiving!!!

http://www.earlyamerica.com/earlyamerica/firsts/thanksgiving/thankstext.html